About Us

Meet the Amatos

Mike and Kristina Amato opened Overtime Pizzeria and Sports Pub in 2016 and have been serving up some of Southwest Florida’s best pizza and family-friendly food ever since. 

 

Originally from Philadelphia, Mike developed his artistry in his Sicilian family’s 45-year-old establishment, Angelo’s Pizza & Ristorante. Since those days, Mike and Kristina have opened and operated three successful restaurants—Nemos—a pizza shop on the Jersey Shore with two locations, Overtime Pizzeria and Sports Pub, and The Loft at OT, the new upscale establishment above Overtime which opened in late 2020. 

 

In their free time, Mike and Kristina enjoy boating along the coastal waterways with their son, Alexander, and their dog, Tony.

Upcoming Events

  • Visit with Santa!
    Thu, Dec 16
    Overtime Pizzeria & Sports Pub
    Visit with Santa!
    Santa Claus has been spotted on his way to Overtime for his final family photo night! From 6-8pm rock your favorite Christmas clothes and bring an unwrapped gift to receive 10% off your bill!
  • Visit with Santa!
    Tue, Dec 21
    Overtime Pizzeria & Sports Pub
    Visit with Santa!
    Santa Claus has been spotted on his way to Overtime for his final family photo night! From 6-8pm rock your favorite Christmas clothes and bring an unwrapped gift to receive 10% off your bill!
  • Closed for Christmas
    Sat, Dec 25
    Overtime Pizzeria & Sports Pub
    Closed for Christmas
    Merry Christmas from our family to yours! We are closed in observation of the holiday.
_DSC8145.jpg
TheLoft_Logo_Vertical_OneColor_White.png

Just upstairs from Overtime is The Loft at OT, an upscale lounge featuring a full liquor bar, and a wide selection of craft cocktails, wines, craft beers, tapas and live entertainment. Open Wednesday through Saturday from 5 p.m. to late.